Coffee extract adds a deep, roasty note to brownies, chocolate cake, frosting, tiramisu and hot cocoa without watering them down the way brewed coffee can. Store-bought bottles can be hard to find, but homemade coffee extract takes only two ingredients and a little patience. Start it in early November and it will be ready for holiday baking and homemade gifts.
What coffee extract is (and is not)
Like vanilla extract, coffee extract is made by steeping a flavoring ingredient, here coffee beans, in alcohol. The alcohol pulls out flavor and aroma and keeps the extract stable on the shelf. It is meant to be used by the teaspoon in recipes, not sipped like a drink or a coffee liqueur.
Coffee extract is also different from cold brew concentrate, which is made with water, must be refrigerated and keeps only a short time. If you want a coffee drink rather than a baking flavoring, see our cold brew starter guide.
What you need
- About 1/2 cup (roughly 40 to 45 g) whole coffee beans or very coarsely ground coffee
- 1 cup (240 ml) plain vodka, around 80 proof
- A clean glass jar with a tight lid
- A fine strainer and a paper coffee filter
- Small clean bottles for storing or gifting
Recipes vary, and you can use more beans for a stronger extract. Plain vodka is popular because it has little flavor of its own; bourbon or rum work too and add their own character. Alcohol must be bought by adults of legal drinking age.
Choosing the coffee
Use coffee you enjoy drinking, because its flavor carries straight into the extract. A medium or dark roast gives a classic mocha-friendly flavor. Whole beans that are lightly cracked are easiest to strain; coarsely ground coffee extracts faster but needs more careful filtering. Coffees sold for cold brew in whole bean or coarse grind, such as Cold Brew Breakfast Blend, are a convenient choice. If you bake for people who avoid caffeine, a decaf such as Cold Brew Swiss Water Decaf gives coffee flavor with far less caffeine.
How to make coffee extract, step by step
- Crack the beans. Put whole beans in a zip-top bag and tap them with a rolling pin until most are broken into a few pieces. You want cracked, not powdered.
- Combine. Add the coffee to the jar, pour in the vodka, and make sure all the coffee is covered.
- Seal and label. Close the lid tightly and label the jar with the date.
- Steep. Keep the jar in a cool, dark cupboard for about one to two weeks. Many people steep longer for a stronger flavor. Give the jar a gentle shake every day or two.
- Taste. After a week, dip a spoon in and taste a drop. When it tastes strongly of coffee, it is ready.
- Strain. Pour through a fine strainer to remove the beans, then again through a paper coffee filter to catch fine particles. Take your time; this can be slow.
- Bottle. Funnel the extract into clean bottles and cap them tightly.
How to store it
Keep the extract tightly capped in a cool, dark place. Because it is mostly alcohol, it keeps for a long time; if it ever smells off or looks moldy, throw it out. Keep it out of reach of children, as you would vanilla extract.
Quick alcohol-free option
For an alcohol-free coffee flavoring, dissolve instant espresso powder in a small amount of hot water to make a thick paste and use it right away. It is not shelf-stable, but it works in frostings and batters.
How to use coffee extract
- Brownies and chocolate cake: add 1 to 2 teaspoons to deepen the chocolate flavor.
- Frosting and whipped cream: stir in a little at a time and taste.
- Holiday desserts: brush the sponge of a coffee yule log with syrup flavored with extract, or add a splash to the glaze on a cinnamon streusel coffee cake.
- Hot cocoa: a few drops add a subtle mocha note.
Coffee extract as a homemade gift
Small amber or clear bottles of homemade extract make thoughtful gifts for bakers. Add a handwritten label with the date and a favorite recipe card. Bundle a bottle with a bag of coffee for a coffee-lover gift, or tuck one into a coffee gift basket. Start your batch at least two weeks before you plan to give it.
FAQ
How long does homemade coffee extract take?
Plan on about one to two weeks of steeping, longer for a stronger extract, plus time to strain and bottle.
Can I use ground coffee instead of beans?
Yes, but use a coarse grind and strain it through a paper filter. Fine grounds make the extract cloudy and are hard to remove.
Does coffee extract contain caffeine?
Yes, some, since it is made from coffee. Recipes use small amounts. Use decaf beans if caffeine is a concern.

Top image: roasted coffee beans in a jar by A S M Jobaer, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
We run the NicheStuff store; some links in this post go to products we sell.
Discover more from Coffee Stuff
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
